Maine must realize trapping is not stewardship | Letter to the Editor of the Portland Press Herald by Serena Ross

              

The Oct. 19 report “Interest in trapping grows in Maine” describes new trappers taking up the practice to build outdoor skills and make hats and mittens. That framing deserves an honest look at what it asks of wild animals.

A trap is violence. A beaver held underwater until they drown, a fox gripped by the leg through a freezing night, a bear restrained by a cable waiting for the person who will kill them; these are not abstractions. They are living beings experiencing pain, fear and death so that someone can enjoy a hobby or own a fur hat. In 2026, no one in Maine needs a trapped animal’s pelt to stay warm.

The article speaks of ethics and good decisions in the field. Real ethics begins with a simpler question: Is this harm necessary? For recreation and fashion, the answer is “no.”

Trapping is often defended as stewardship. True stewardship protects wildlife and the ecosystems they hold together. It solves conflicts with humane tools like education on coexistence, non-lethal repellents, fencing and good old-fashioned tolerance. It would never turn unnecessary pain, terror and premature death into a pastime and call it conservation.

Maine’s wildlife are not raw material for crafts or a challenge to master. They are our neighbors. A state that valued them would stop treating their suffering as recreation.

Serena Ross
Belfast


Governor Elect Hannah Pingree has asked for the ideas of Mainers. Please go to Pingree’s transition website and at the bottom on the page speak out for Maine’s wildlife.